Toddlers May Gain More From Paper Books Than E-Books: Study

Toddlers May Gain More From Paper Books Than E-Books: Study

By Dennis Thompson, ( 

When it comes to reading to toddlers, apparently there is no substitute for an old-fashioned book.

That's according to new research that found paper books foster better parent-child interactions than electronic books do.

This held true even when comparing print books against very basic e-readers that don't contain distracting elements like sound effects or animation, noted lead researcher Dr. Tiffany Munzer. She is a fellow in developmental behavior pediatrics at the University of Michigan's C.S. Mott Children's Hospital.

"Parents and children also had a lower quality of interaction over even this basic electronic book without these fancier features," Munzer said. "There's something about the tablet itself. These devices do not lend themselves to a shared experience."

Parents and toddlers talked more when reading print books, and were more apt to work together to perform tasks like holding the book and turning pages, Munzer and her colleagues found.

Toddlers presented with an e-book became more focused on the tasks of tapping or swiping the screen, instead of focusing on the story being told or the parent reading to them.

Parents also became distracted with e-books, tending to talk less about the story and more about the device itself. For example, they might spend more time telling the toddler how to work the tablet and less time actually reading from it.

The findings were published online March 25 in the journal Pediatrics.

"We always thought the enhanced e-books, with all their distractions, interfered with reading," said Dr. Suzy Tomopoulos, an assistant professor of pediatrics at the NYU School of Medicine. "But it wasn't only the enhancements that made these books underperform. I think it also has to do with the fact that they are harder to share and more individual."

Previous research has shown that preschoolers and young school-age children tend to gain less from reading e-books than print books, the researchers said in background notes. The kids appear to have lower...(click here to continue reading)

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in ThinkerNation - Blog

Normalize Setbacks By Asking Your Kids For Advice When You Struggle
Normalize Setbacks By Asking Your Kids For Advice When You Struggle

Organizational psychologist Adam Grant says protecting kids from struggle may be counterproductive. He shared one tactic he uses with his own children.

Read More

Impulse Control Techniques That Work for Children  - ThinkerNation
Impulse Control Techniques That Work for Children

A lack of impulse control is at the root of many behavior problems. An impulsive 6-year-old may hit when he doesn't get his way and an impulsive 16-year-old may share inappropriate content on social media without thinking about the potential ramifications.

Without appropriate intervention, impulsive behaviors can get worse over time. But the good news is, you can teach your child impulse control techniques.

The more impulse control your child gains, the less likely he'll be to grab things out of your hand and he'll be more likely to...

Read More

10 Tips for Raising Mentally Strong Kids - ThinkerNation
10 Tips for Raising Mentally Strong Kids

Mentally strong kids are prepared for the challenges of the world. They’re able to tackle problems, bounce back from failure, and cope with hardships. 

To be clear, mental strength isn't about acting tough or suppressing emotions. It's also not about being unkind or acting defiant.

Instead, mentally strong kids are resilient and they have the courage and confidence to reach their full potential.

Helping kids develop mental strength requires a three-pronged approach: teaching them to replace negative thoughts with more realistic thoughts, helping them learn to control their emotions so their emotions don’t control them, and showing them how to take positive action.

Read More